Assessing our squad

Manchester United chat
User avatar
Jason
Legend
Posts: 1154
Joined: 12 years ago

fat maradona wrote: 7 months ago
fat maradona wrote: 2 years ago
JoelfuckingGlazer wrote: 2 years ago Shaw out for the season. Probably fucks us for top 4 with Martinez out too.

We need a new left back. Can't trust Shaw to stay fit for a season. That awful injury at a young age messed him up.
Now we’ll regret selling Alvaro Fernandez. Better than Malaccia and still only 20.
We really are shit tbh. We let Alvaro go on loan and replaced him with Reguilon on loan from Spurs. And then we didn’t bother exercising the £14m buy back to instead spend £30m on Dorgu. And Real end up spending £50m on him and he’ll go on to be a class LB.
It's not a great look tbh, but I'm not sure he'd have been ready for us when reguillion was signed. In saying that, was reguillion ready!?

Let's hope dorgu continues to develop, and reaches similar level as alvaro so that it doesn't look so stupid!
User avatar
Felwin
Legend
Posts: 3244
Joined: 12 years ago
Location: Abroad

Jason wrote: 7 months ago
fat maradona wrote: 7 months ago
fat maradona wrote: 2 years ago
JoelfuckingGlazer wrote: 2 years ago Shaw out for the season. Probably fucks us for top 4 with Martinez out too.

We need a new left back. Can't trust Shaw to stay fit for a season. That awful injury at a young age messed him up.
Now we’ll regret selling Alvaro Fernandez. Better than Malaccia and still only 20.
We really are shit tbh. We let Alvaro go on loan and replaced him with Reguilon on loan from Spurs. And then we didn’t bother exercising the £14m buy back to instead spend £30m on Dorgu. And Real end up spending £50m on him and he’ll go on to be a class LB.
It's not a great look tbh, but I'm not sure he'd have been ready for us when reguillion was signed. In saying that, was reguillion ready!?

Let's hope dorgu continues to develop, and reaches similar level as alvaro so that it doesn't look so stupid!
It's a load of bollocks, aye. And it will be proper annoying if he goes on to have a great career in Madrid.

The one thing I will say is that we didn't exercise the buyback because then Madrid would just have bid the same and Alvaro would have the choice. So it was more a case of accept the mistake and take a bit of cash. Still fucking dense though,

I heard that Ten Hag thought Alvaro was more suited to a back 3/5 so wouldn't do well at United... a few months later we hire a coach who plays a back 3/5. Everywhere you look, idiotic decisions have been made.
User avatar
dozer
Silver Bullshit
Posts: 5031
Joined: 12 years ago

Felwin wrote: 7 months ago
Jason wrote: 7 months ago
fat maradona wrote: 7 months ago
fat maradona wrote: 2 years ago
JoelfuckingGlazer wrote: 2 years ago Shaw out for the season. Probably fucks us for top 4 with Martinez out too.

We need a new left back. Can't trust Shaw to stay fit for a season. That awful injury at a young age messed him up.
Now we’ll regret selling Alvaro Fernandez. Better than Malaccia and still only 20.
We really are shit tbh. We let Alvaro go on loan and replaced him with Reguilon on loan from Spurs. And then we didn’t bother exercising the £14m buy back to instead spend £30m on Dorgu. And Real end up spending £50m on him and he’ll go on to be a class LB.
It's not a great look tbh, but I'm not sure he'd have been ready for us when reguillion was signed. In saying that, was reguillion ready!?

Let's hope dorgu continues to develop, and reaches similar level as alvaro so that it doesn't look so stupid!
It's a load of bollocks, aye. And it will be proper annoying if he goes on to have a great career in Madrid.

The one thing I will say is that we didn't exercise the buyback because then Madrid would just have bid the same and Alvaro would have the choice. So it was more a case of accept the mistake and take a bit of cash. Still fucking dense though,

I heard that Ten Hag thought Alvaro was more suited to a back 3/5 so wouldn't do well at United... a few months later we hire a coach who plays a back 3/5. Everywhere you look, idiotic decisions have been made.
I think I read somewhere that he wanted to leave to Spain because he was homesick but I'm not sure. The club probably had to let him go.
Disclaimer: This post is likely to be WUMming. Irritate yourself with it at your own risk
User avatar
dozer
Silver Bullshit
Posts: 5031
Joined: 12 years ago

We've got about 5 days left and we've not sold shit!
Disclaimer: This post is likely to be WUMming. Irritate yourself with it at your own risk
User avatar
JoelfuckingGlazer
Legend
Posts: 5970
Joined: 12 years ago

Mount injured again, that's why he came off at HT. What a fucking surprise.
Fuck the Glazers
Legend
Posts: 12641
Joined: 12 years ago

JoelfuckingGlazer wrote: 5 months ago Mount injured again, that's why he came off at HT. What a fucking surprise.
Cunha's injury is gonna fuck us as well.

It's worth keeping an eye on the injuries. Ineos have revamped aka sacked a lot of the medical staff. Also the head of sport medicine, Gary O'Driscoll, who Ineos poached from Arsenal and is regarded as the best in the business, left in March this year. So did the first team doctor.

Hopefully there's nothing untoward going on there. But the point being there should be less injuries this season, especially with a reduced number of games.
User avatar
Felwin
Legend
Posts: 3244
Joined: 12 years ago
Location: Abroad

One of our new signings and one of our best players so far this season injured. And Dozer was ready to work with a 15-man squad or whatever.

No excuses to not play Kobbie now.
User avatar
Felwin
Legend
Posts: 3244
Joined: 12 years ago
Location: Abroad

Dunno where to post tactics stuff, but I've just listened to the tactics pod from Ed and the lads and it's massively improved IMO. Think they were spot on with saying we've been good on second balls and I 100% agree that we need that flexibility to give teams something to think about. That long ball to Sesko will have to become a weapon as the season develops and it will make the opposition question whether to press us or give us the ball. At the moment it's one or the other, either we go direct like against Arsenal and Burnley, compete for second balls, look dangerous but then lose control of the game to chaos. Or we attempt to control the game among the back 5-7 and can't find a way through like against Fulham.

I worry that Amorim and his team are still not effectively judging the opposition and the best strategy but it is true what the lads say in the pod that the first 4 games have been theatrical and it's made it emotional and dramatic. Amorim of course hasn't helped but having a shite keeper is a large part of why it's been dramatic.
User avatar
JoelfuckingGlazer
Legend
Posts: 5970
Joined: 12 years ago

Felwin wrote: 5 months ago Dunno where to post tactics stuff, but I've just listened to the tactics pod from Ed and the lads and it's massively improved IMO. Think they were spot on with saying we've been good on second balls and I 100% agree that we need that flexibility to give teams something to think about. That long ball to Sesko will have to become a weapon as the season develops and it will make the opposition question whether to press us or give us the ball. At the moment it's one or the other, either we go direct like against Arsenal and Burnley, compete for second balls, look dangerous but then lose control of the game to chaos. Or we attempt to control the game among the back 5-7 and can't find a way through like against Fulham.

I worry that Amorim and his team are still not effectively judging the opposition and the best strategy but it is true what the lads say in the pod that the first 4 games have been theatrical and it's made it emotional and dramatic. Amorim of course hasn't helped but having a shite keeper is a large part of why we've been shit.
Its a good summary. I often find that my thought process and outlook is very different between the real-time emotion of games and the emotionless aftermath.

I completely agree that the keeper situation has grossly exagerated the negative, and really compromised us. The data and eye-test for our league games has been broadly good. A good 90 mins against Arsenal that should have yielded a point, a good 45 against Fulham, and a good 80 against Burnley. We need to keep reminding ourselves that its a work in progress, and we have to keep moving the focus away from the manager, to building the squad. All in all, its been a decent window - we still need 4 or 5 quality players to be a proper side, but that's do-able over the next 2 windows. Most of the expensive dross has been binned off - we still have Casemiro but he's gone in 12 months, Maguire serves a purpose and his contract is up anyway in 12 months. Then there's Mount and Shaw, but if we can keep them reasonably fit then they play a role. Just Onana, and I have a feeling he'll be off to Turkey/Saudi in the next fortnight.

If Lammens comes good, and we add a quality Centre Back, 2 Centre Mids and another wing back, we're actually able to become a very good side.

We really need to make the most of the eased fixture list this season, play every game with full intensity and if we can navigate City and Chelsea unbeaten, then we have Brentford and Sunderland. We just need to be up and around the top 6 until Christmas to limit any talk and atmosphere of crisis.
fat maradona
Legend
Posts: 1615
Joined: 12 years ago

The media circus has helped fan the flames for the doom and gloom of the first 4 games but the stats say different, if these are to be believed

https://x.com/jamestactics/status/19628 ... QP4I7InbHQ
Post Reply