The State of Play: NQAT x The Promised Land Crossover
#884 | In this crossover episode of ‘No Question About That’ and ‘The Promised Land’ Ed chats to Scott Saunders, about a myriad of topics surrounding United. They the club’s difficulties this past year, particularly the struggles with transfers and the inevitable media frenzy that surrounds each deal. They evaluate the club’s state-of-the-union, potential incoming and outgoing transfers, and the importance of patience for fans during the rebuild process. There is a strong emphasis on the need for a new goalkeeper, striker, and midfielder to enhance the team’s spine. The hosts also touch on player development, the intricacies of dealing with underperforming, high-wage players, and the financial realities facing the club.
00:00 Introduction
00:58 Remembering a Friend
02:08 Current State of the Club
04:04 Transfer Market Media Hysteria
10:33 Analyzing Potential New Signings
29:37 Bruno’s Adaptation
31:27 Challenges with Market Dynamics
33:55 Financial Constraints and Ownership Issues
34:49 Contract Dilemmas
51:23 Youth Development
52:35 Reflections on the Club’s State
55:00 Closing Remarks
If you are interested in supporting the show and accessing exclusive bonus episodes check out our Patreon page. No Question About That is available on YouTube, Apple, Spotify, Amazon and all podcast apps. Hit that subscribe button, leave a rating and write a review. Get in touch on Twitter and Instagram.
Episode Summary
This crossover discussion on “No Question About That” and “The Promised Land” podcasts covers the intricacies of Manchester United’s current state. Hosted by Scott Saunders and Ed Barker, the conversation explores the club’s challenges and prospects, touching on topics ranging from transfers and player performances to strategic future planning.
Reflecting on the Past Year
The dialogue kicks off reminiscing about a tumultuous year at the club. Ed mentioned his interactions with Rob Blanchette, reminiscing about the journey of launching “The Promised Land” podcast and the unintentional path that led him into it. Both hosts share their struggles with adapting to the demands of modern broadcasting, such as speaking directly to the camera, which feels unnatural. Scott recounts the challenges of the past year, including the loss of a friend and how it impacted his journey. Their experiences serve as a microcosm of the club’s turbulence, highlighting both personal and professional struggles.
Current Club Dynamics
Ed and Scott dig into the club’s dynamics, analyzing the state of player transfers and negotiations. Scott expresses frustration over inaccuracies and repetitive reporting within the media, specifically pointing to how United’s transfer dealings play out publicly. Ed agrees, emphasising how the media often amplifies stories, creating hysteria over every minor development. This frenzy can exhaust fans, as speculation becomes widespread, yet often unfounded.
Summer Transfers and Challenges
The episode’s central discussion revolves around summer transfers. Ed reminisced about the late signings of previous years, pointing out that the process often drags due to multiple complex factors. Both Scott and Ed agreed that the club’s negotiations are not necessarily slower than others, but they are scrutinised more intensely. This scrutiny is evident in their discussion of players like Mathias Cunha and Brian Mbuemo. While both players bring potential, concerns linger about their ultimate impact. Ed mentions the tendency for players to overperform compared to their expected outcomes, spotlighting the delicate balance United faces in strengthening their lineup.
Strategic Planning and Financial Realities
Scott expresses a desire for a new goalkeeper, emphasizing the importance of reliable defense. Ed highlights the need for sensible financial decisions, particularly bearing in mind United’s past spending missteps, like Harry Maguire’s acquisition, which saw them eventually paying the original, hefty asking price after extensive negotiations. The duo also touch on United’s financial strategy, pondering potential reorientation of ownership and the implications of Jim’s potential incremental share purchase.
Player Development and Expectations
A significant portion of the discussion is dedicated to assessing player development pathways and setting realistic expectations. Scott advocated for patience with young talents like Kobbie Maino, suggesting that clamoring for immediate results could stunt their growth. Ed further elaborates on player development, referencing Alejandro Garnacho’s promising trajectory despite off-field distractions. He urges fans to recognise that budding stars like Kobbie Mainoo won’t fit into certain roles immediately, and that development takes time.
Navigating Player Exits
The conversation also explores potential departures. Ed and Scott speculate on exits for players such as Marcus Rashford and Jadon Sancho. They suggested Rashford might leave on loan, perhaps to Barcelona, while Sancho’s high wages could complicate any permanent deal. Scott expresses hope for a workable solution that satisfies all parties involved. Both acknowledged these delicate situations are influenced by broader market conditions and the club’s internal dynamics.
Navigating Forward
In closing, Scott and Ed embrace the need for patience as United and its fanbase navigate forward. They anticipate a period of incremental improvement, and expressed optimism that with strategic planning and sensible transfers, progress can be achieved in due time. Reflecting on past challenges and future opportunities, this podcast episode underscores the complexity of rebuilding United into a formidable club on both a domestic and international stage.